Already weighing named firms? See how we compare with Greystar, Asset Living, CBRE and JLL, including when each is the better choice.
A scorecard to use
| Criterion | Suggested weight | Evidence to request |
|---|---|---|
| Performance on comparable assets | 30% | NOI vs budget and renewal or retention data, for assets like yours |
| Team and staffing | 20% | Names, property counts per manager, turnover on the team |
| Reporting and data | 20% | A real sample package and live dashboard access |
| Total cost | 15% | A full fee schedule, modeled on your rent roll |
| Transition plan | 10% | A dated plan and a named lead |
| Compliance and legal | 5% | Licenses, insurance, audit results, any litigation |
RFP questions worth asking
Performance
- Show NOI vs budget for your three most comparable assets over the past three years.
- Which clients left in the past two years, and why? May we call one?
- Give an example of a recommendation you made that an owner rejected. What happened?
Team
- Who specifically will work on our assets, and how many other properties do they cover?
- Who employs the on-site staff, and what was their turnover last year?
Money
- Is your fee calculated on collected, billed or gross potential rent?
- List every other fee, reimbursement and payroll allocation we could be charged.
- Do you or your affiliates earn income from vendors, insurance or tenant programs?
Data and technology
- How soon after month-end do we get reports, and can we see data before then?
- Who owns the data, and in what format do we get it back when we leave?
- Which tasks are automated, and how are the results checked?
- What data does your pricing tool use? See AI rent pricing compliance for why this matters.
Check the license and the insurance
Many states treat leasing or handling rent for other owners as licensed real estate activity, and the rules vary. Texas, for example, has a specific exemption for on-site apartment managers that doesn't extend to condominiums or townhomes, and rental agents who solicit prospects by phone must be licensed.1 Ask for license details for each state you own in. Also ask for proof of errors and omissions, crime and fidelity coverage, and confirm limits with your insurance adviser.
Compare proposals on the same numbers
Model every proposal on your actual rent roll. Then compare the fee with what the manager can credibly do to NOI. On a 1,500-unit portfolio collecting $27.6M, one point of fee is about $276,000 a year. Three percent off a typical operating budget is about $390,000 (see our fee guide). So the cheapest proposal may not be the least expensive one.
Red flags
- Performance shown only as portfolio averages, with no asset detail
- The team you met in the pitch isn't the team on your assets
- Fees described as "standard," with no complete schedule
- Sample reports that have been built specially for the pitch
- No answer when you ask about clients they've lost
