The formula
Loss to lease ($) = market rent − in-place rent.
Loss to lease (%) = (market rent − in-place rent) ÷ market rent.
Be careful: sources differ on the denominator. Wall Street Prep divides market rent by actual rent and subtracts 1, which turns a $2,000 market rent and $1,820 in-place rent into about 9.9%.1 Dividing by market rent gives 9.0%. Pick a method, and use the same one across your whole portfolio. On a pro forma, it usually appears as a deduction from gross potential rent, so we divide by market rent.
Worked example
| Item | Calculation | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Units | 300 | |
| Market rent | Per month | $1,800 |
| Average in-place rent | Per month | $1,728 |
| Monthly gap per unit | $1,800 − $1,728 | $72 |
| Loss to lease % | $72 ÷ $1,800 | 4.0% |
| Annual loss to lease | 300 × $72 × 12 | $259,200 |
| Implied value at 5.75% cap | $259,200 ÷ 5.75% | About $4.5M |
That last line is what makes it so appealing in an offering memo, and also why you should question it. You'd only capture all of it if every lease moved to market with no added turnover, and the market estimate was right.
How much can you actually capture?
- Timing: leases must expire first, so even a full capture takes about a year.
- Turnover risk: pushing a renewal to market can cost a resident. At nearly $4,000 a turn,2 that can wipe out years of the increase.
- Market accuracy: a "market rent" set too high inflates the loss. Check it against recent signed leases, not asking rents.
- Legal limits: rent regulation, affordability restrictions or local caps can limit increases.
Gain to lease
When in-place rents exceed market, you have gain to lease. In a falling market, that's a warning: your rents may need to fall when leases expire. It's common during heavy new supply, and is easy to miss if your market rents aren't updated.
How to reduce it
- Update market rents from signed leases and competitor data, within applicable law. See AI rent pricing compliance.
- Rank by unit, and set the renewal offer according to the gap and the resident's renewal risk.
- Stagger lease expirations, so more leases expire during strong leasing months.
- Separate concessions from rent, so you see the effective rate.
- Measure trade-outs, which show whether each new lease actually improved on the old one.
Reading it as an asset manager
| What you see | What it may mean |
|---|---|
| High, and growing | Market rising faster than pricing, or market rents set too high |
| High on one floor plan | Specific pricing error or mix issue |
| Near zero, with high vacancy | Priced at market but not leasing, so test whether market rent is accurate |
| Negative | Gain to lease. Expect pressure at renewal |
Loss to lease is one part of the path to economic occupancy, so read them together.
