The signs, and how to test them
| # | Sign | How to test it |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Reports arrive late or keep changing | Log delivery dates and restatements over six months |
| 2 | NOI misses plan with vague explanations | Ask for a variance by line item, with a stated cause and fix |
| 3 | Physical occupancy looks fine, but cash doesn't | Compare economic and physical occupancy |
| 4 | Retention or renewals are falling | Trend it over 12 months, and compare it with your market |
| 5 | Controllable expenses are rising faster than peers | Compare per-unit or per-SF costs with benchmarks and your other assets |
| 6 | Delinquency keeps growing | Review aging by bucket, and sample collection actions |
| 7 | You hear about problems from someone else | Count the surprises in the past year |
| 8 | Work orders stay open | Pull time-to-complete, and tenant or resident complaints |
| 9 | Vendor invoices don't add up | Sample 25 invoices against contracts and approvals |
| 10 | Your team leaves, and nobody tells you | Ask for staff changes on your assets in the past year |
Separate the manager from the market
A soft submarket, heavy new supply or an insurance spike can hurt NOI under any manager. Before you decide, ask three questions:
- Did comparable properties in the same submarket do better over the same period?
- Was the plan realistic when it was set?
- Did the manager flag the problem early and propose a response?
The third often matters most. A manager who warned you in March and acted is different from one who explained it in December.
What to try first
- Put it in writing. List the issues, the measures and a date.
- Ask for a recovery plan with owners and dollar targets.
- Change the team. Sometimes the fix is a different regional or property manager.
- Get an outside view. Size the gap with an NOI leakage review.
- Review 90 days later. If nothing measurable moved, you have your answer.
Keep your records throughout. If the agreement allows termination for cause, the documentation will matter, so involve counsel.
What it costs to wait
Each point of economic occupancy on a 300-unit community at $1,800 is about $64,800 a year. At a 5.75% cap rate, that's about $1.1M of value. Compare that with the cost of a transition, and you'll have the real size of the decision.
If you decide to move
Don't tell the current manager until your plan is ready. Line up your replacement, read your notice terms, and follow our switching guide. To compare candidates, use our selection scorecard.
