Worked example
| Year | Expenses per SF | Above base | Tenant pays on 10,000 SF |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2026, base year | $12.00 | $0.00 | $0 |
| 2027 | $12.60 | $0.60 | $6,000 |
| 2028 | $13.25 | $1.25 | $12,500 |
| 2029 | $13.90 | $1.90 | $19,000 |
The tenant pays this on top of base rent. With a $34 rent, the owner still bears the first $12 in expenses, so it's roughly equivalent to a $22 net rent in year one.
Base year vs expense stop vs NNN
| Structure | Owner pays | Tenant pays |
|---|---|---|
| Base year | Costs up to the base year's level | Share of the increase |
| Expense stop | Costs up to a fixed dollar amount per SF | Share above that amount |
| NNN | Non-recoverable costs | Share of all recoverable costs |
The key difference is that a base year isn't known when the lease is signed, while a stop is. Read more in NNN vs gross vs modified gross.
The gross-up issue
A building that's only partly occupied during the base year has unusually low variable costs. If those aren't grossed up, later years, at higher occupancy, can show a jump that tenants see as unfair. If the lease requires grossing up both the base year and comparison years, the comparison is on the same footing.
| Base year at 70% occupancy | Variable cost per SF |
|---|---|
| Actual | $4.00 |
| Grossed up to 95%: $4.00 × 95 ÷ 70 | $5.43 |
That's a difference of $1.43 per SF in the starting point. The treatment changes what a tenant owes for the entire term, so check it carefully. Gross-ups generally apply to variable costs, not fixed items like taxes, and misapplying them is a common dispute.1
Pitfalls for owners
- A base year set by unusual costs. A year with one-time expenses inflates the base and reduces later recoveries. Consider how you'd treat those items.
- Tax appeals. If a tax appeal lowers the base year's taxes, or a later year's, the lease may require adjustments.
- Expense category changes. Adding a new service later can be disputed if it wasn't in the base. Check the lease.
- Caps. A cap on controllable expenses can reduce what you can bill.
- Different base years in one building. Each tenant needs its own calculation, so errors are easy to make, and hard to spot.
- Missed billing. Some leases limit how long you can wait to bill, so check your deadlines.
What to check on your portfolio
- List each tenant's base year in your lease abstract, and verify it against the lease and any amendments.
- Check the occupancy level used in each base year calculation.
- Reset base years correctly at renewal, when the lease requires it. A renewal usually resets the base, which wipes out accumulated recoveries, so include that in your net effective rent comparison.
- Test one tenant's calculation from scratch each year. See CAM reconciliation.
