What a successful appeal is worth
| Item | Current assessment | After appeal |
|---|---|---|
| Assessed value | $20,000,000 | $17,500,000 |
| Tax at 2.5% | $500,000 | $437,500 |
| Annual saving | $62,500 | |
| Value at a 5.75% cap rate | About $1.09M |
Property taxes are often one of the largest operating expenses. NAA's 2024 sample put taxes and insurance combined at $2,998 per unit, or about a third of operating expenses, as reported by Baselane.1
How to test whether you have a case
Income-producing property is usually valued using the income approach. Run a quick version yourself:
- Find the assessed market value. Check your local assessment ratio, because some assess at a fraction of market value.
- Estimate value by income. Stabilized NOI divided by a market cap rate.
- Check comparable sales and assessments of similar properties nearby.
- Look at property facts. Is the assessor's area, age, class or condition wrong? Those errors are often the easiest to fix.
- Compare. If the assessment is well above your supported value, it's worth a professional look.
Evidence to gather
- T12s and the last three years of operating statements
- Current rent roll and vacancy history
- Recent purchase details, an appraisal if you have one, and any listing history
- Repair needs from a condition report
- Market evidence: rents, vacancy and cap rates
- Photos and documentation of property problems
Before you submit anything, ask how your income data will be treated. Filings can sometimes become public, so check confidentiality rules.
The process
- Watch for notices. Note the filing deadline as soon as your assessment arrives. If you miss it, you may lose the right to appeal for that year.
- Try informal review, where available. Some assessors will correct errors without a hearing.
- File the formal appeal with the right body and forms.
- Present the case to the local board.
- Go further if justified, to a state board or court.
Rules vary a lot, and you may need to keep paying taxes during the appeal. Confirm details with your assessor or local counsel. A corporate-owned property may also require an attorney to appear.
Who should handle it?
| Option | Fits when | Check |
|---|---|---|
| In-house | A simple factual error | Time, and your local procedures |
| Consultant | Income-based value argument | Their fee and local track record |
| Attorney | Larger assets, or an appeal to a higher level | Whether representation is required |
Many work on contingency, so get the terms in writing. Is the fee based on one year's savings or several? Who pays filing and appraisal costs? What happens if savings are reversed?
Who keeps the savings?
On NNN and base year leases, tenants may be entitled to their share of a refund, and possibly must share in the costs of getting it. Check the leases before you budget the savings, then reflect them in your reconciliation. A lower base year can also reduce your future recoveries.
Risks
- Your income data and the sale price can cut against you if they support the assessment.
- In some places, the board may be able to raise the value as well.
- Appeal costs can outweigh savings on a small difference.
