Owners and asset managers: see where your portfolio's NOI is leaking. Schedule a free working session
ORI tenants

Commercial tenant rollover risk: how to measure it and get ahead of it.

Rollover risk is the chance that NOI falls when commercial leases expire and tenants leave or renegotiate. Measure it by mapping expirations by year, assigning each major tenant a renewal probability and calculating the expected cost of each path. Replacing a tenant usually costs several times as much as renewing one.

Updated November 6, 2026 · Opennova

Dark glass office tower seen from below against a gray sky

Renewal vs replacement math

Illustrative: 20,000 SF office, $30/SF, 5-year lease. Costs vary widely by market
CostRenewReplace
Downtime at $30/SF$0$450,000 (9 months)
Tenant improvements$300,000 ($15/SF)$1,200,000 ($60/SF)
Leasing commission on $3M lease value$60,000 (2%)$180,000 (6%)
Free rent$0$250,000 (5 months)
Total$360,000$2,080,000

These are illustrative assumptions, not benchmarks, so use your broker's current figures for your market. Here, replacing the tenant costs $1,720,000 more than renewing.

Weight it by probability

Expected cost = (renewal probability × renewal cost) + (1 − renewal probability) × replacement cost.

From the example above
Renewal probabilityExpected costSaved vs 60%
60%$1,048,000n/a
70%$876,000$172,000
80%$704,000$344,000

On this one lease, each 10 points of renewal probability is worth $172,000. That's the business case for spending time with the tenant early.

Map your exposure

  • Expiration schedule: the percentage of base rent and SF expiring each year, by asset and across the fund.
  • Top-tenant concentration: how much income the largest five tenants provide.
  • Options: renewal, termination and contraction rights that could change the date. These are easy to overlook.
  • Timing against debt: expirations near a loan maturity or planned sale, when they matter most.
  • Market position: the in-place rent compared with today's market. A tenant far above market will expect a cut, even if it stays.

Early warning signs

  • Late payments, or a change in who approves them
  • Reduced use of the space, or fewer people on site
  • Subleasing, or inquiries about it
  • Rising complaints, or complaints stopping altogether
  • Changes at the tenant: merger, new leadership or layoffs
  • A tenant's broker asking for a lease copy or space comparisons

In one Opennova case study, a mixed-use operator flagged 3 at-risk tenants early after adding tenant risk modeling.

A 24-month playbook for major tenants

Months to expiryAction
24Update the file: options, financials, usage, and the decision maker
18Senior-level check-in, to learn about the tenant's space plans
12–15Open the renewal conversation, ahead of their broker's process where possible
9–12Send a proposal, and prepare a backup leasing plan
6If no deal, market the space

Adjust this to the tenant's size and notice requirements. Large tenants often start well before this, and option notice dates may fall earlier than the schedule above.

By asset type

  • Office: space-use changes and flight to quality, where TI and free rent can be large.
  • Retail: anchor and co-tenancy effects, as well as store sales where reported.
  • Industrial: single-tenant binary risk. One departure may leave a building 100% vacant.

Questions owners ask.

What is rollover risk in commercial real estate?

It's the risk that income falls when leases expire, whether from a tenant leaving, downtime and re-leasing costs, or renewing at a lower rent.

What is a lease rollover schedule?

It's a table showing the percentage of base rent and square footage expiring in each year, typically over the next five to ten years.

How much does it cost to replace a commercial tenant?

It varies by market and type. It generally includes downtime, tenant improvements, commissions and free rent, and often costs several times as much as a renewal. Use current local broker estimates.

When should you start a commercial lease renewal?

For major tenants, 12 to 24 months before expiration is common, and earlier if there's an option notice date or a large space requirement.

Keep reading.

Find your next rollover problem early.

Tell us about the portfolio. We'll identify your highest-impact opportunities within 48 hours, then work through them with you.

Free · No obligation · Confidential
Schedule a working session