Renewal vs replacement math
| Cost | Renew | Replace |
|---|---|---|
| Downtime at $30/SF | $0 | $450,000 (9 months) |
| Tenant improvements | $300,000 ($15/SF) | $1,200,000 ($60/SF) |
| Leasing commission on $3M lease value | $60,000 (2%) | $180,000 (6%) |
| Free rent | $0 | $250,000 (5 months) |
| Total | $360,000 | $2,080,000 |
These are illustrative assumptions, not benchmarks, so use your broker's current figures for your market. Here, replacing the tenant costs $1,720,000 more than renewing.
Weight it by probability
Expected cost = (renewal probability × renewal cost) + (1 − renewal probability) × replacement cost.
| Renewal probability | Expected cost | Saved vs 60% |
|---|---|---|
| 60% | $1,048,000 | n/a |
| 70% | $876,000 | $172,000 |
| 80% | $704,000 | $344,000 |
On this one lease, each 10 points of renewal probability is worth $172,000. That's the business case for spending time with the tenant early.
Map your exposure
- Expiration schedule: the percentage of base rent and SF expiring each year, by asset and across the fund.
- Top-tenant concentration: how much income the largest five tenants provide.
- Options: renewal, termination and contraction rights that could change the date. These are easy to overlook.
- Timing against debt: expirations near a loan maturity or planned sale, when they matter most.
- Market position: the in-place rent compared with today's market. A tenant far above market will expect a cut, even if it stays.
Early warning signs
- Late payments, or a change in who approves them
- Reduced use of the space, or fewer people on site
- Subleasing, or inquiries about it
- Rising complaints, or complaints stopping altogether
- Changes at the tenant: merger, new leadership or layoffs
- A tenant's broker asking for a lease copy or space comparisons
In one Opennova case study, a mixed-use operator flagged 3 at-risk tenants early after adding tenant risk modeling.
A 24-month playbook for major tenants
| Months to expiry | Action |
|---|---|
| 24 | Update the file: options, financials, usage, and the decision maker |
| 18 | Senior-level check-in, to learn about the tenant's space plans |
| 12–15 | Open the renewal conversation, ahead of their broker's process where possible |
| 9–12 | Send a proposal, and prepare a backup leasing plan |
| 6 | If no deal, market the space |
Adjust this to the tenant's size and notice requirements. Large tenants often start well before this, and option notice dates may fall earlier than the schedule above.
By asset type
- Office: space-use changes and flight to quality, where TI and free rent can be large.
- Retail: anchor and co-tenancy effects, as well as store sales where reported.
- Industrial: single-tenant binary risk. One departure may leave a building 100% vacant.
