Start with the math
Retention is usually worth paying for, but not at any price. Before making an offer, put a replacement next to a renewal. The figures below are a sample for a 20,000 SF office tenant at $30 per SF. Our rollover risk guide has a fuller version.
| Renew at $28 | Replace at $30 | |
|---|---|---|
| Downtime | None | 9 months: $450,000 |
| Tenant improvements | $5 per SF: $100,000 | $40 per SF: $800,000 |
| Commissions | $50,000 | $180,000 |
| Free rent | 1 month: $46,667 | 5 months: $250,000 |
| Upfront cost | $196,667 | $1,680,000 |
| Rent over 5 years | $2,800,000 | $3,000,000 |
| Net over 5 years | $2,603,333 | $1,320,000 |
On those assumptions, a discount of $2 per SF looks small next to what a move-out costs. Your numbers will differ, so run them. A tenant paying far above market or sure to shrink is a different decision, and you might be better off with a smaller renewal or new tenant.
A retention timeline
| Months to expiry | What to do |
|---|---|
| Always | Keep response times low. Log every complaint, and check the tenant's business health |
| 24 to 18 | Executive check-in for larger tenants. Ask about headcount, space and plans |
| 18 to 12 | Prepare an estimate of renewal terms, plus the replacement math. Fix open issues |
| 12 to 9 | Make the first proposal. Their broker may already be looking |
| 9 to 6 | Negotiate. Decide what you'd trade, such as term for TI or expansion rights |
| 6 to 0 | Close, or begin marketing the space in parallel |
Eight strategies that actually help
- Survey, then act publicly. Run a satisfaction survey, and tell tenants what you changed because of it.
- Know the decision maker. The office manager who submits work orders and the executive who signs the renewal have different concerns. Build relationships with both.
- Fix repeat problems. Three calls about the same HVAC zone cost more goodwill than one long outage. Track repeats in your work order data.
- No billing surprises. Warn tenants about big CAM or tax changes before the invoice arrives. Tenants who audit are often tenants who felt surprised.
- Offer flexibility. Expansion, contraction and early renewal options can solve a tenant's real problem for less than a large TI package.
- Consider blend-and-extend. Lower rent now in exchange for a longer term can work for both of you. Test it on net effective rent.
- Watch for warning signs. Sublease listings, emptying floors, late payments, new leadership and silence all deserve a call.
- Give someone ownership. Every lease rolling within 24 months should have a named person and a dated plan.
What tenants say matters
A 2019 Kingsley study found that 37% of office tenants named property management as a key reason to renew. Among medical office tenants likely to renew, it was 30%.2 Dated, but the point stands: management is one of the few renewal factors you can change this quarter. See our guide to tenant experience for what else goes into it.
Where we fit
For the buildings we manage, our AI models tenant risk and rollover sensitivity, then flags at-risk tenants early so that outreach happens while it can still change the outcome. In one anonymized case, a mixed-use operator using our AI with their own team flagged three at-risk tenants early. Results vary by portfolio.
