Qualify before anyone gets on site
- Business entity, W-9 and any required trade licenses
- Insurance that meets your minimums, verified as described below
- Workers' compensation or a legally valid exemption
- References on comparable buildings
- A signed contract with scope, pricing and terms
- A safety record, for higher-risk trades
Insurance: where the mistakes happen
A certificate of insurance is evidence of coverage, and doesn't itself create or expand it. The policy and endorsements control.1 Three points cause most of the trouble:
- Additional insured status comes from the policy. Listing your name in a certificate's description box doesn't necessarily make you an additional insured, so verify the endorsement.1
- Primary and noncontributory wording means the vendor's insurance should respond first, without seeking a share from yours. Writing those words on a certificate isn't enough if the policy doesn't support them.1
- Dates lapse. Check coverage is current, and track renewal dates. Consider higher limits for high-risk work.2
The written contract matters as much as the certificate. It should set out the insurance obligations and the indemnification terms, and counsel should review it, since these provisions depend on state law.1
Bids and approval limits
| Purchase size | Sample control |
|---|---|
| Under $2,500 | Manager may approve, within budget |
| $2,500 to $10,000 | Two bids, with the manager's written choice |
| $10,000 to $50,000 | Three bids, with owner approval |
| Over $50,000 | Written scope, bid leveling, owner approval, and possibly an outside reviewer |
| Emergencies | Act first, notify the owner quickly, and document it |
Don't bid only once. Recurring contracts like landscaping, janitorial, elevators and security tend to drift upward. Set a rebid schedule, and read the auto-renewal clauses.
Conflicts of interest
This is where owners should ask direct questions, because the money doesn't always show up on a statement.
- Does the manager or an affiliate own or earn from any vendor?
- Does the manager receive rebates, referral fees or volume discounts, and who keeps them?
- Is there a markup on materials or on in-house labor?
- Are construction management fees charged on top of vendor markups?
None of these is automatically wrong, and a manager's purchasing scale can be a real advantage. JLL, for example, says its marketplace delivers an average 14% procurement savings.3 But savings claims are worth testing on your own contracts, and every arrangement should be disclosed. Our fee guide and commercial fee guide list common add-ons.
A simple vendor scorecard
| Vendor | Annual spend | On-time | Repeat calls | Insurance current | Last bid |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Elevator | $48,000 | 96% | 2 | Yes | 2023 |
| HVAC | $96,000 | 88% | 9 | Yes | 2025 |
| Janitorial | $210,000 | 91% | 14 | Expired | 2021 |
Reviewing a table like this takes minutes, and shows what to rebid first. In this sample, janitorial is the priority: the largest spend, the oldest bid, the most repeat calls and an expired policy.
What to do during a takeover
When you change managers, confirm which contracts are in the owner's name, which can be assigned, and which end with the outgoing manager. Master contracts held by a manager may not transfer.
