Why it matters
A $100,000 cost treated as an expense lowers NOI by $100,000. At a 6% cap rate, that implies about $1.67M less value. Treated as capital, it doesn't touch NOI at all. The cash is the same either way, which is why the classification deserves attention.
Common examples
| Usually opex | Usually capex | Depends on the facts |
|---|---|---|
| Routine repairs and cleaning | New roof | Roof section or patch |
| Painting a turned unit | Full unit renovation | Appliance replacement |
| HVAC servicing | New HVAC system | Major HVAC component |
| Landscaping contract | Repaving a parking lot | Sealing and striping |
Set a written policy with a dollar threshold, and apply it across every property. For tax, the answer can differ from your management reports, so talk with your tax adviser.
The IRS tests
Under the IRS tangible property rules, a unit of property is improved, and the cost is capitalized, only if the amount is paid for:1
- Betterment: fixing a defect that predates acquisition, adding material capacity, or materially increasing output or efficiency.
- Restoration: replacing a major component or substantial structural part, or returning a deteriorated asset to working order.
- Adaptation: converting the property to a new or different use.
IRS safe harbors
| Safe harbor | Summary from the IRS |
|---|---|
| Routine maintenance | Recurring work to keep a building system in efficient operating condition, reasonably expected to occur more than once in 10 years |
| De minimis | Up to $2,500 per invoice or item, or $5,000 with an applicable financial statement, by annual election |
| Small taxpayer | Average gross receipts of $10M or less and building basis under $1M, with annual qualifying spending up to the lesser of 2% of basis or $10,000 |
These are simplified. See the IRS page for the conditions.1
Capital reserves
Lenders often require replacement reserves, and the amount usually depends on the loan program and the property's condition, so ask your lender. Whether reserves appear above or below your NOI line differs by convention, so always check when comparing NOI. A property condition assessment is the usual way to size real needs.
How to review your portfolio
- Compare repairs and capex per unit or SF across similar properties.
- Sample capex invoices. Does each meet your policy?
- Compare repair spending before and after any change in manager or policy.
- Check how major items affect recoveries. Under commercial leases, tenants generally can't be charged for capital items unless the lease allows it.2
- Measure the return on capex against plan. Our value-add page shows how.
