Owners and asset managers: see where your portfolio's NOI is leaking. Schedule a free working session
Operations

Replacement reserves: how much to set aside, and what they do to your numbers.

Replacement reserves are funds set aside for future capital replacements like roofs and HVAC. Common underwriting conventions are about $250 to $300 per apartment unit a year and about $0.15 to $0.25 per square foot for commercial, though older assets often need more.1 Investors often leave them out of NOI, while lenders often include them.2

Updated November 6, 2026 · Opennova

Apartment block with an orange and white facade and rows of balconies

Common conventions

From MMCG Invest's review of HUD, CMBS and agency conventions, July 2026
Asset typeConvention per yearEvidence-based range
Multifamily$250 per unit$250 to $400+ per unit, by age
Retail$0.15 per SF$0.20 to $0.35 per SF
Office$0.20 to $0.25 per SF, with TI and leasing costs separate$0.15 to $0.25 per SF for Class A structural, higher for older stock
Industrial and small-bay flex$0.05 to $0.15 per SFLease carve-outs can move six-figure replacements to the landlord
Self-storage$0.12 to $0.15 per SFSame range

Treat these as starting floors. MMCG presents them as historical conventions, and your lender's documents and property condition assessment take priority.1 A flat $250 per unit may have no connection to what a 1985 garden community will really need.

Reserves and NOI

People disagree about where reserves belong, and the answer changes your value. Wall Street Prep describes the usual pattern: investors often exclude reserves from NOI so properties can be compared, lenders often include them for a more conservative figure, and sellers exclude them to support a higher price.2

A $100,000 reserve changes value on paper and can move DSCR below a 1.25x minimum. It doesn't change the cash flow itself.2
Wall Street Prep's exampleReserves excludedReserves included
NOI$1.1M$1.0M
Implied value at a 5% cap rate$22M$20M
DSCR1.26x1.15x

So when comparing deals, confirm how each NOI figure was built. Then rerun coverage in our DSCR calculator using your lender's method.

Build a plan from the bottom up

  1. List major components: roofs, HVAC, paving, elevators, boilers, facades and unit interiors.
  2. Record age, condition and remaining life, using a PCA and service records.
  3. Estimate replacement cost with current bids where you can.
  4. Spread the cost over the years to replacement, and add an inflation assumption.
  5. Compare the result with what you're funding now.
Sample data, with no inflation or interest. On 100,000 SF, this is $1.30 per SF a year, far above a $0.20 convention
ComponentCost todayYears leftAnnual funding
Roof, 60,000 SF$540,0006$90,000
10 rooftop units$160,0008$20,000
Parking lot$120,0006$20,000
Total$820,000$130,000

That gap is the point of this exercise. A building can meet the lender's minimum and still be underfunded for what's coming. Add the shortfall to your hold-period capital plan, or you'll meet it later as a capital call. Our deferred maintenance guide shows how to rank what's already overdue.

Questions to ask your manager

  • What did we fund, draw and leave unspent last year, and do those tie to the bank and lender statements?
  • Are lender-held reserve draws being submitted on time?
  • Have any planned replacements moved, and why?
  • Are repairs being coded to capital in a way that flatters NOI?

Questions owners ask.

How much should I set aside for replacement reserves?

Conventions start around $250 to $300 per apartment unit and $0.15 to $0.25 per square foot for commercial. Older assets often need more, so base the real figure on a component list and a property condition assessment.

Are replacement reserves included in NOI?

It varies. Investors often exclude them, while lenders often include them. There's no single rule, so check how any NOI figure you're reading was calculated.

Are replacement reserves the same as capex?

No. Reserves are money set aside, and capex is money spent. A draw from reserves can pay for capex, but the two are tracked separately.

Are replacement reserves tax deductible?

Setting cash aside usually isn't an expense by itself. The tax treatment generally follows the later spending, and your tax adviser can confirm how it applies to you.

Sources

Checked November 6, 2026. Many industry figures come from vendors or trade groups, so we say who published each one. Test them against your own market.

  1. MMCG Invest, replacement reserves in commercial real estate. Advisory firm, July 22, 2026, compiling HUD, CMBS and agency conventions. Not a lender's guide, so confirm against your loan documents
  2. Wall Street Prep, replacement reserves. Financial training firm

Keep reading.

Find out if your reserves match your buildings.

Tell us about the portfolio. We'll identify your highest-impact opportunities within 48 hours, then work through them with you.

Free · No obligation · Confidential
Schedule a working session